Now readingArticle

CLARITY Act moves to a fight between cops and coders

Back to TopTopShare

Top Categories

  • Bitcoin News](/content/news/bitcoin/index.html)
  • Ethereum News](/content/news/ethereum/index.html)
  • XRP News](/content/news/xrp/index.html)
  • Solana News](/content/news/solana/index.html)

Trending Now

SpaceX’s IPO exposes the first crack in tokenized stocks – fragmented ownership and allocationTokenizationJun 13, 2026](/content/spacexs-ipo-exposes-the-first-crack-in-tokenized-stocks/index.html)

Latest Crypto News

The future of vaults: neobanks and invisible DeFiDeFiJun 13, 2026](/content/the-future-of-vaults-neobanks-and-invisible-defi/index.html) US export order removes Anthropic Mythos model access fueling crypto bets on AI that is beyond government reachAIJun 13, 2026](/content/us-anthropic-fable-mythos-crackdown-fuels-crypto-bet-on-ai-that-is-beyond-government-reach/index.html)

Coverage

Market Movers

Market Views

Popular Prices

  • Bitcoin](/content/coins/bitcoin/index.html)
  • Ethereum](/content/coins/ethereum/index.html)
  • XRP](/content/coins/xrp/index.html)
  • Solana](/content/coins/solana/index.html)

Sectors

Ecosystems

  • Ethereum](/content/blockchain/ethereum/index.html)
  • Binance Chain](/content/blockchain/binance-chain/index.html)
  • Solana](/content/blockchain/solana/index.html)
  • Polygon](/content/blockchain/polygon/index.html)

California Governor Election WinnerXavier Becerra 88.9%](/content/predictions/market/california-governor-election-2026/index.html) Knicks vs. SpursSpurs 64.5%](/content/predictions/market/nba-nyk-sas-2026-06-13/index.html) **Will the Iranian regime fall by June 30?**No 99.1%](/content/predictions/market/will-the-iranian-regime-fall-by-june-30/index.html) **Kharg Island no longer under Iranian control by…?**August 31 7%](/content/predictions/market/kharg-island-no-longer-under-iranian-control-by-march-31/index.html)

View all trending markets

Crypto Politics Sports Finance Tech Culture

Global Elections Bitcoin Iran US Election NBA Tech Aliens Business Economic Policy Formula 1

Recent

Tennessee Strategic Bitcoin Reserve Act (HB 1695)ExpiredHB1695 would have authorized Tennessee’s state treasurer to invest limited eligible state funds in Bitcoin with caps, custody...](/content/crypto-laws/tennessee-strategic-bitcoin-reserve-act-hb-1695/index.html) South Dakota HB 1155: State Bitcoin Investment BillExpiredSouth Dakota HB 1155 would have permitted the State Investment Council to invest up to 10% of eligible...](/content/crypto-laws/south-dakota-hb-1155-state-bitcoin-investment/index.html) Strategic Digital Assets Reserve Act of South Carolina (H. 4256)In committeeSouth Carolina H. 4256 would authorize State Treasurer investment in certain digital assets, including Bitcoin, under proposed reserve,...](/content/crypto-laws/south-carolina-h-4256-strategic-digital-assets-reserve-act/index.html)

Jurisdictions

  • United States](/content/crypto-laws/jurisdiction/united-states/index.html)
  • European Union](/content/crypto-laws/jurisdiction/european-union/index.html)
  • Singapore](/content/crypto-laws/jurisdiction/singapore/index.html)
  • United Kingdom](/content/crypto-laws/jurisdiction/united-kingdom/index.html)
  • India](/content/crypto-laws/jurisdiction/india/index.html)

Topics

Statuses

Law Types

Guide Series

Guide SeriesBuy Borrow DieBy CoinRabbitExplore why savvy investors borrow against crypto instead of selling, with insights on liquidity,...View series](/content/guides/series/buy-borrow-die/index.html) Guide SeriesInstitutional PlaybookBy WhiteBITExplore WhiteBIT’s Institutional Playbook, a 3-part guide series on exchange due diligence, crypto-as-a-service, and...View series](/content/guides/series/institutional-playbook/index.html)

View all series

Recent Guides

Crypto Basics Beginner What Is a Testnet and How Do Crypto Testnets Work?Before real funds move on a blockchain, developers and users test everything on a testnet....](/content/guides/what-is-a-testnet-and-how-do-crypto-testnets-work/index.html) DeFi Beginner Zero-Knowledge Proof (ZK Proof): What It Is and How It WorksZK proofs show up everywhere in crypto, from rollups to identity systems to shielded payments....](/content/guides/zero-knowledge-proof-zk-proof-what-it-is-and-how-it-works/index.html) Crypto Basics Beginner What Is Mainnet in Crypto And How Does It Work?A mainnet is the live version of a blockchain, where real money moves, fees are...](/content/guides/what-is-mainnet-in-crypto-and-how-does-it-work/index.html) Crypto Basics Beginner What Is the MACD Indicator and How To Use It?The MACD indicator is one of the most-used tools in crypto trading, but most beginners...](/content/guides/what-is-macd-indicator-how-to-use-it/index.html)

View all guides

Guide Categories

Crypto BasicsStart learning crypto with beginner-friendly guides to wallets, trading, blockchain,... DeFiExplore DeFi guides covering wallets, dapps, staking, liquidity, lending, yield,... BitcoinLearn Bitcoin basics with guides to BTC wallets, mining, security,... Wallet SecurityLearn wallet security basics, from addresses and seed phrases to... NFTs

Browse all categories

Review Categories

Browse Directory

Company Verticals

Product Categories

People Categories

Company

Help & Legal

Follow

Section Navigation

News

Latest News

SpaceX’s IPO exposes the first crack in tokenized stocks – fragmented ownership and allocationTokenizationJun 13, 2026](/content/spacexs-ipo-exposes-the-first-crack-in-tokenized-stocks/index.html) The future of vaults: neobanks and invisible DeFiDeFiJun 13, 2026](/content/the-future-of-vaults-neobanks-and-invisible-defi/index.html) US export order removes Anthropic Mythos model access fueling crypto bets on AI that is beyond government reachAIJun 13, 2026](/content/us-anthropic-fable-mythos-crackdown-fuels-crypto-bet-on-ai-that-is-beyond-government-reach/index.html) Wholesale inflation is back in focus. Here’s what PPI means for your money and BitcoinMacroBearishJun 13, 2026](/content/wholesale-inflation-is-back-in-focus-heres-what-ppi-means-for-your-money-and-bitcoin/index.html)

Asset Coverage

  • Bitcoin news](/content/news/bitcoin/index.html)
  • XRP news](/content/news/xrp/index.html)
  • Ethereum news](/content/news/ethereum/index.html)
  • Solana news](/content/news/solana/index.html)

Topic Coverage

Market Structure

Coins

Coin Views

Prices

  • Bitcoin price](/content/coins/bitcoin/index.html)
  • Ethereum price](/content/coins/ethereum/index.html)
  • XRP price](/content/coins/xrp/index.html)
  • Solana price](/content/coins/solana/index.html)

Sectors

Ecosystems

Prediction Markets

Prediction Markets

Laws

Browse

Recent

Tennessee Strategic Bitcoin Reserve Act (HB 1695)ExpiredHB1695 would have authorized Tennessee’s state treasurer to invest limited eligible state funds in Bitcoin with caps, custody...](/content/crypto-laws/tennessee-strategic-bitcoin-reserve-act-hb-1695/index.html)

South Dakota HB 1155: State Bitcoin Investment BillExpiredSouth Dakota HB 1155 would have permitted the State Investment Council to invest up to 10% of eligible...](/content/crypto-laws/south-dakota-hb-1155-state-bitcoin-investment/index.html) Strategic Digital Assets Reserve Act of South Carolina (H. 4256)In committeeSouth Carolina H. 4256 would authorize State Treasurer investment in certain digital assets, including Bitcoin, under proposed reserve,...](/content/crypto-laws/south-carolina-h-4256-strategic-digital-assets-reserve-act/index.html)

Jurisdictions

Topics

Statuses

Law Types

Learn

Featured Guides

Buy Borrow DieWhy long-term crypto holders borrow against assets instead of selling](/content/guides/why-long-term-crypto-holders-borrow-against-assets-instead-of-selling/index.html) Buy Borrow DieWhy collateral reuse is the hidden risk in crypto lending](/content/guides/why-collateral-reuse-is-the-hidden-risk-in-crypto-lending/index.html) Buy Borrow DieCapital preservation in practice: how major players use high-LTV crypto-backed loans](/content/guides/buy-borrow-die-high-ltv-crypto-loans/index.html) Institutional PlaybookThe Market Maker’s Exchange Checklist (Liquidity, Latency, and Risk Controls)](/content/guides/the-market-makers-exchange-checklist-liquidity-latency-and-risk-controls/index.html) Institutional PlaybookCrypto-as-a-Service Playbook: How Banks, Telcos, and Fintechs Launch Crypto Products Fast, Safely, and Compliantly](/content/guides/crypto-as-a-service-playbook-how-banks-telcos-and-fintechs-launch-crypto-products-fast-safely-and-compliantly/index.html)

Guide Categories

Reviews

Review Categories

Directory

Browse Directory

Company Verticals

Product Categories

People Categories

More

Company

Help & Legal

Follow

Search CryptoSlateSearch CryptoSlateesc

Searching...

No resultsTry a different name or ticker.

Jun. 12, 2026at 9:59 am GMT•UpdatedJun. 12, 2026at 11:09 am GMT• 5 min read

Quick Take

  1. 01 White House officials met with law enforcement groups to debate Section 604, the CLARITY Act provision most likely to block a Senate vote.
  2. 02 The provision would shield many developers and infrastructure providers, while leaving exchanges and hosted wallets inside the compliance perimeter.
  3. 03 Law enforcement says broad safe-harbor language could weaken crypto crime cases, and compromise language remains under discussion.

[MakeCryptoSlatepreferred on")

Share on XShare on FacebookShare on TelegramShare on LinkedInShare via email

On June 10, administration officials hosted law enforcement groups at the White House to resolve the provision most likely to block the CLARITY Act from reaching the Senate floor for a vote.

As Eleanor Terrett reported, the meeting drew around 20 attendees over nearly 90 minutes, with developer protections drawn from the Blockchain Regulatory Certainty Act (BRCA) dominating the agenda.

Section 604 of the Senate draft defines a “non-controlling developer or provider” as one lacking the legal right or unilateral ability to control, initiate, or effectuate user transactions without another party's approval.

Advertise with CryptoSlate

Under that definition, the provision limits money-transmitter treatment to parties who actually control or move assets, leaving developers who write distributed-ledger software, provide self-custody tools, or support blockchain infrastructure outside that classification.

\ \ Related Reading New Coinbase CLARITY Act standoff over stablecoin reward is now holding up rules for the entire US crypto market \ \ The Senate’s crypto bill is stuck in a noisy fight over stablecoin rewards, but its real impact would be much broader.\ \ Mar 27, 2026·Gino Matos](/content/coinbase-standoff-over-stablecoin-reward-clarity-is-now-holding-up-rules-for-the-entire-us-crypto-market/index.html)

Actor or activity Has unilateral control over user funds? Protected under BRCA? Why it matters
Open-source software developer No Likely yes Writing or publishing code alone would not trigger money-transmitter status.
Self-custody wallet provider No Likely yes User controls private keys; provider does not move funds for the user.
Node, oracle, or infrastructure provider No Likely yes Supporting blockchain infrastructure is treated differently from operating a financial service.
Front-end operator with admin keys or transaction control Possibly Unclear / fact-specific This is where compromise language may narrow the safe harbor.
Exchange, broker, dealer, or hosted wallet Yes No These actors intermediate customer activity and remain inside the compliance perimeter.
Developer knowingly facilitating illicit transfers Not the only issue No safe harbor if criminal intent applies Industry argues criminal liability survives where there is knowing facilitation.

Where law enforcement draws the line

Cortez Masto, in her statement following the Senate Banking vote, said the current version of the CLARITY Act “undermines law enforcement's ability to trace illicit finance and recover victims' money, while at the same time creating a more challenging environment to prosecute criminals for knowingly transmitting illicit funds.”

Her amendments targeting decentralized platform enforcement were ruled out of order during the markup before Chairman Tim Scott later reinstated several others.

In an April 21 letter to Senate Banking leadership, the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP) said Section 604 would limit prosecutors' ability to pursue financial crime cases involving cryptocurrency, arguing that the safe harbor could strip law enforcement of statutes used to prosecute criminals operating on digital asset infrastructure.

The fear is prosecutorial: that broad safe-harbor language gives criminals a structural shield by protecting the layers of infrastructure prosecutors currently use as pressure points.

TRM Labs estimated illicit crypto volume reached $158 billion in 2025, up nearly 145% from 2024, while the FBI's 2025 Internet Crime Report found cryptocurrency investment fraud alone generated $7.2 billion in reported losses.

The industry's counterargument

White House crypto adviser Patrick Witt called the CLARITY Act a “pro-regulatory, pro-enforcement bill” during a Blockchain Association town hall, pushing back against law enforcement groups who argue the bill falls short on financial crime.

A coalition supported by the Blockchain Association submitted a letter signed by 160 former law enforcement, intelligence, and national security officials, arguing that the legislation would improve oversight through expanded sanctions tools, greater coordination with Treasury, and updated asset-seizure powers.

TRM Labs documented the bill's architecture, divided into:

Provision What it does Who it affects Enforcement value
Title II Applies BSA, SAR, and OFAC-style obligations to digital commodity brokers, dealers, and exchanges. Centralized crypto market intermediaries. Brings more crypto activity into AML, sanctions, and suspicious-activity reporting frameworks.
Section 203 Creates a five-year public-private information-sharing pilot. Treasury, law enforcement, regulators, exchanges, analytics firms, and other private-sector participants. Gives investigators and compliance teams a formal channel to share illicit-finance intelligence.
Section 305 Preserves temporary hold authority. Digital asset service providers and stablecoin issuers. Allows suspicious transactions to be paused before funds move beyond recovery.
Section 308 Mandates blockchain analytics tools in certain compliance contexts. Covered digital asset firms and intermediaries. Turns blockchain tracing and risk monitoring into part of the statutory compliance toolkit.
BRCA / Section 604 Limits money-transmitter treatment for non-controlling developers and providers. Developers, self-custody providers, and infrastructure operators without control over user assets. Protects software builders while leaving controlled intermediaries and knowing bad actors exposed.

TRM also argues that criminal liability for knowing facilitation of criminal proceeds survives BRCA under 18 USC § 1960(b)(1)(C). The safe harbor covers non-controlling developers, and knowing participants in illicit finance retain full criminal exposure under existing statute.

The industry's core pitch is that regulated, US-based markets give investigators better visibility than developers pushed offshore by legal uncertainty.

The vote math

Warner and Cortez Masto have tied their floor votes to law enforcement's satisfaction with the final text.

The bill needs 60 Senate votes, requiring at least seven Democrats beyond the two who voted yes in committee. Gallego and Alsobrooks, who supplied the decisive committee votes, have conditioned floor support on further movement on ethics and enforcement.

Senate lawmakers working to reach an ethics agreement came away empty-handed this week.

The Senate has just 31 session days remaining before the August recess, which lawmakers and lobbyists view as the unofficial deadline before Congress turns its focus to midterm elections.

Stifel's chief Washington policy strategist, Brian Gardner, noted that if the Senate fails to act before August, the bill's prospects will deteriorate materially.

DeFi Education Fund confirmed BRCA is among the most important provisions for developers and infrastructure providers, and the bill's developer constituency depends on it surviving intact.

CryptoSlate Daily Brief

Daily signals, zero noise.

Market-moving headlines and context delivered every morning in one tight read.

5-minute digest 100k+ readers

Email address

Get the brief

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Whoops, looks like there was a problem. Please try again.

You’re subscribed. Welcome aboard.

The more plausible path runs through a clearer intent or knowledge standard restricting the safe harbor to developers with no knowing involvement in laundering, tighter language around “non-controlling” status for front-end operators, relayers, or parties holding admin keys, and a savings clause stating explicitly that BRCA preserves criminal prosecution authority for knowing facilitation of illicit finance.

Each of those additions gives Senate Democrats a floor-defense line while keeping the provision's core protection for non-controlling developers intact.

Two ways this ends

In the bull case, law enforcement groups move from active opposition to neutrality, a lower bar than endorsement but sufficient political cover for Warner, Cortez Masto, and the remaining Democrats needed to reach 60.

A narrowed BRCA survives alongside strengthened reporting, analytics, and intent requirements, the bill reaches the floor before August, and developers keep the core protections, prosecutors keep the criminal carve-out, and the US gets its first comprehensive digital asset market structure law.

In the bear case, the gap between law enforcement's demand for prosecutorial flexibility and the industry's demand for developer protection proves unbridgeable before the calendar closes.

An accord among Senate lawmakers to resolve the ethics debate collapsed this week, and the bill misses the August recess deadline.

Regulatory uncertainty extends into 2027 and beyond, with enforcement-by-interpretation holding as the framework and offshore venues retaining structural advantages over US-based operators.

The odds on Polymarket of a CLARITY Act approval this year have moved from 74% to 48% over the past month, reflecting both risks being priced in simultaneously.

Scenario What changes before August What happens to BRCA Senate vote implication Market impact
Bull case: cops move to neutral Law-enforcement groups accept revised language preserving prosecutorial tools. BRCA survives with clearer intent, knowledge, and savings-clause language. Moderate Democrats get enough cover to move toward 60 votes. U.S. market-structure clarity becomes plausible in 2026.
Base case: talks continue, clock tightens Negotiators narrow BRCA but do not fully satisfy law enforcement or developer groups. Developer protections remain, but front ends, relayers, and admin-key operators face tighter language. Vote math remains possible but fragile. Markets price uncertainty; U.S. firms delay compliance and product decisions.
Bear case: gap remains unbridgeable Law-enforcement groups keep objecting while ethics talks also stall. BRCA becomes a floor-vote liability. Democrats withhold support; bill misses the pre-August window. Enforcement-by-interpretation continues into 2027; offshore venues retain an advantage.

The political test for moderate Democrats is whether developer protections and prosecutorial tools can coexist in the same bill, and whether they can defend that answer on a Senate floor in a midterm year.

Warner and Cortez Masto have made their votes contingent on law enforcement's satisfaction, setting the threshold at neutrality.

A statement from the FOP that revised language adequately preserves prosecutorial tools may well clear that bar. Whether the June 10 meeting moved the conversation that far will be revealed by next week's Senate negotiations.

TRM Labs](/content/companies/trm-labs/index.html) Polymarket](/content/companies/polymarket/index.html)

Featured US Regulation Culture Banking

Advertise with CryptoSlate

Context

Related coverage

Explore related reporting by asset, place, or topic.

USRegulation

\ \ Tokenization\ \ SpaceX’s IPO exposes the first crack in tokenized stocks – fragmented ownership and allocation \ \ SpaceX is exposing the first big crack in tokenized stocks: everyone can trade the name, but not everyone owns the same thing.\ \ 1 hour ago](/content/spacexs-ipo-exposes-the-first-crack-in-tokenized-stocks/ "SpaceX’s IPO exposes the first crack in tokenized stocks – fragmented ownership and allocation"/index.html)

\ \ AI\ \ US export order removes Anthropic Mythos model access fueling crypto bets on AI that is beyond government reach \ \ The US move against Anthropic’s Fable 5 and Mythos 5 shows how quickly frontier models can become national security assets.\ \ 5 hours ago](/content/us-anthropic-fable-mythos-crackdown-fuels-crypto-bet-on-ai-that-is-beyond-government-reach/ "US export order removes Anthropic Mythos model access fueling crypto bets on AI that is beyond government reach"/index.html)

\ \ MacroBearish\ \ Wholesale inflation is back in focus. Here’s what PPI means for your money and Bitcoin \ \ Bitcoin’s inflation-hedge narrative faces a near-term test as hot PPI data pushes rate-cut hopes lower and risk assets come under pressure.\ \ 7 hours ago](/content/wholesale-inflation-is-back-in-focus-heres-what-ppi-means-for-your-money-and-bitcoin/ "Wholesale inflation is back in focus. Here’s what PPI means for your money and Bitcoin"/index.html)

\ \ Tokenization\ \ Crypto exchanges are opening a two-front war for the stock market \ \ Crypto exchanges are racing to sell stocks like crypto, opening a fight for users with each other and a bigger battle with Wall Street.\ \ 1 day ago](/content/crypto-exchanges-are-opening-a-two-front-war-for-the-stock-market/ "Crypto exchanges are opening a two-front war for the stock market"/index.html)

\ \ Adoption\ \ UK funds could soon add crypto ETNs, but FCA keeps exposure on a 10% leash \ \ The FCA plan could bring crypto exposure into mainstream funds, but only through listed notes and strict controls.\ \ 3 days ago](/content/uk-mutual-funds-may-soon-be-allowed-to-hold-crypto-etns-but-only-with-a-10-leash/ "UK funds could soon add crypto ETNs, but FCA keeps exposure on a 10% leash"/index.html)

CryptoSlate may use AI tools to support research, editing, and production workflows. Published articles remain editorially reviewed by our team. Read our full AI usage disclaimer.

Our writers' opinions are solely their own and do not reflect the opinion of CryptoSlate. None of the information you read on CryptoSlate should be taken as investment advice, nor does CryptoSlate endorse any project that may be mentioned or linked to in this article. Buying and trading cryptocurrencies should be considered a high-risk activity. Please do your own due diligence before taking any action related to content within this article. Finally, CryptoSlate takes no responsibility should you lose money trading cryptocurrencies. For more information, see our company disclaimers.

×

Expand

More about